Tool & Vendor Comparison Builder · governed release 03
Compare options without letting the shiny parts erase the hard questions. Frame one bounded decision, compare the current process with two candidates, preserve the evidence behind each judgment, and keep unresolved privacy, security, accessibility, verification, or exit conditions visible.
Go directly to the builder ↓ Private working space
Frame one comparison Nothing entered here is transmitted to Aloha AI. Do not paste confidential, privileged, personal, security-sensitive, or regulated information.
Restoring your local comparison… Jump to download and reset controls ↓
Gates control. A high weighted score never cancels an unresolved or failed gate.
Decision to be made State one bounded choice; do not assume buying a tool is the answer. Outcome and baseline What should improve, for whom, and compared with what current result? Scope and exclusions Define users, setting, data, duration, consequences, and prohibited uses. Accountable owner Name the person with decision authority. Required reviewers Identify privacy, security, access, legal, procurement, domain, or affected-party review.
01 Criterion weightsWeight each criterion from 0–5 before comparing. Arithmetic organizes your judgments; it does not make them objective.
Bounded task fit Does the option support the stated outcome within scope? Operational fit Can the responsible team review, maintain, support, and govern it? Total burden Consider money, implementation, review, training, remediation, switching, and ongoing work.
02 Current processOption name Option type
Do not advance 5 gate(s) failed or unresolved. Repair and obtain required review before ranking controls a decision.
Privacy, data authority, and acceptable use The information, permissions, retention, model-training terms, and uses are lawful and acceptable for this bounded context.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Security and incident response Required security controls, vulnerability handling, incident notice, and responsible ownership are evidenced.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Accessibility and equitable access The option can meet applicable access needs, accommodations, and procurement requirements without shifting burdens to users.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Evidence and output verification Claims and outputs can be tested against trusted sources by capable reviewers before consequential use.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Exit, portability, and continuity Data and work can be retrieved; lock-in, deletion, transition, and service-failure paths are understood and acceptable.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits 0% weighted arithmetic summary (0/50). This summary is not comparable unless the same scope, evidence standard, reviewers, and weights apply—and it never overrides a gate.
03 Candidate AOption name Option type
Do not advance 5 gate(s) failed or unresolved. Repair and obtain required review before ranking controls a decision.
Privacy, data authority, and acceptable use The information, permissions, retention, model-training terms, and uses are lawful and acceptable for this bounded context.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Security and incident response Required security controls, vulnerability handling, incident notice, and responsible ownership are evidenced.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Accessibility and equitable access The option can meet applicable access needs, accommodations, and procurement requirements without shifting burdens to users.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Evidence and output verification Claims and outputs can be tested against trusted sources by capable reviewers before consequential use.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Exit, portability, and continuity Data and work can be retrieved; lock-in, deletion, transition, and service-failure paths are understood and acceptable.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits 0% weighted arithmetic summary (0/50). This summary is not comparable unless the same scope, evidence standard, reviewers, and weights apply—and it never overrides a gate.
04 Candidate BOption name Option type
Do not advance 5 gate(s) failed or unresolved. Repair and obtain required review before ranking controls a decision.
Privacy, data authority, and acceptable use The information, permissions, retention, model-training terms, and uses are lawful and acceptable for this bounded context.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Security and incident response Required security controls, vulnerability handling, incident notice, and responsible ownership are evidenced.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Accessibility and equitable access The option can meet applicable access needs, accommodations, and procurement requirements without shifting burdens to users.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Evidence and output verification Claims and outputs can be tested against trusted sources by capable reviewers before consequential use.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits Exit, portability, and continuity Data and work can be retrieved; lock-in, deletion, transition, and service-failure paths are understood and acceptable.
Status Unresolved / insufficient evidence Pass for this bounded use Fail / unacceptable condition Evidence, source, date, reviewer, and limits 0% weighted arithmetic summary (0/50). This summary is not comparable unless the same scope, evidence standard, reviewers, and weights apply—and it never overrides a gate.
05 Preserve uncertainty and ownershipUncertainty, conflicting evidence, and dissent Owner-selected next step and conditions
Download readable comparison Export portable JSON Delete local comparison